Unfortunately in this case, Jacka needs to do a lot more, both to individuate himself and to create a stellar series. I like the modern UF detective noir, despite being somewhat formulaic in plot, because I enjoy discovering what the author does with a magic system, characters, setting, and tension. Well, whatever–I can overlook it, right? I don’t hate Harry Dresden. Don’t believe me? You really need to read Carly’s review which analyzes the similarities. I started to wonder, did this get its start as fan fiction? It clearly owes a great deal to Dresden, from the characters to the themes to various plot points. Once you start reading, the parallels appear quickly, beginning with his protagonist, Alex Verus, noting there’s a wizard in Chicago rumored to advertise in the phone book. I can only assume this was so someone wouldn’t sue Jacka for copyright violations on Butcher’s behalf. Of course, my edition gives it away with the cover, where a quote from Jim Butcher plays a prominent role on the jacket. It isn’t long before you notice the first Dresden homage in Jacka’s first adult UF book. One of these things is not like the other: Recommended for: Dresden fans between books Read from May 14 to 15, 2013 ★ ★ 3/4
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |